Back to search
2203.05666

On solutions to the continuum version of the Kuramoto model with identical oscillators

A. R. Krueger, S. Rengaswami, R. N. Leander

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves global C1 well-posedness for the continuum Kuramoto PDE with identical oscillators via an iterative (Picard-type) scheme and characteristics, derives the closed projected-characteristic ODE, and establishes global synchronization (C(t)→1) with at most one exceptional label; these are documented in their Theorem 1 (existence), Theorem 2 (uniqueness), the characterization (204)–(205), and Lemmas 10–14 for asymptotics . The candidate solution reaches the same conclusions but constructs the solution directly in label space by a globally Lipschitz ODE on the circle and then reconstructs ρ via the Jacobian; its asymptotic analysis parallels the paper’s (monotonic order parameter, invariant semicircle, at most one antipodal trajectory, and C(t)→1). The only substantive discrepancy is a minor typographical slip in the paper’s representation (204), where y(t;u) should read y(s;u) inside the time integral; the candidate correctly notes and fixes this. Overall, both proofs are correct and consistent, but methodologically distinct.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The work delivers a careful existence/uniqueness theory and a clean asymptotic synchronization proof for the identical-oscillator Kuramoto PDE using an iterative-characteristics framework that is both rigorous and instructive. Results align with known theory and are presented clearly, with a small typographical error in the solution representation that should be corrected. The connection to numerical methods via the projected-characteristics ODE is a useful byproduct.