Back to search
2204.11688

The Numerical Assembly Technique for arbitrary planar systems based on an alternative homogeneous solution

Thomas Kramer, Michael Helmut Gfrerer

correctmedium confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper assembles an exact-frequency NAT system A(ω)c=0 and asserts that f(ω)=det A(ω) is continuous with infinitely many zero crossings, each zero being a natural frequency; it also motivates and tests an anchored exponential/trigonometric basis W(ξ)=C1 cos(κξ)+C2 sin(κξ)+C3 e^{κ(ξ−L)}+C4 e^{−κξ} that avoids hyperbolic growth and improves conditioning, with supporting figures and discussion . The candidate model provides a (sketched) rigorous functional-analytic justification for discreteness and unboundedness of the spectrum via compact embeddings and a selfadjoint operator, and a precise equivalence between zeros of f and eigenmodes. The core claims align; the paper’s presentation is methodological and empirical (no full proofs), whereas the model supplies the missing spectral-analytic underpinnings. On the numerical side, both agree that the anchored exponential basis is bounded on [0,L] and improves conditioning, as also shown in the paper’s condition-number plots . Overall, the arguments are consistent; the paper is correct in conclusions but does not prove the spectral claims it states, while the model’s proof sketch fills that gap.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper extends NAT to planar frames and provides a clear alternative basis that demonstrably improves conditioning and stability at high frequencies, supported by systematic numerical tests. The central methodological contributions are sound, and the conclusions match observed performance. For completeness, the manuscript should add short theoretical remarks or references justifying continuity of the characteristic determinant, discreteness/unboundedness of the spectrum, and the equivalence between zeros of the frequency function and natural modes under the stated boundary/interface conditions. With these clarifications, the paper would be solid and self-contained for its intended audience.