Back to search
2204.13033

HYPOCOERCIVITY AND HYPOCONTRACTIVITY CONCEPTS FOR LINEAR DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS

Franz Achleitner, Anton Arnold, Volker Mehrmann

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper states (and reduces to) the short-time semigroup-norm expansion via the shifted hypocoercivity index: for B with Hermitian part BH and μ=λmin(BH), if mSHC(B)<∞ then ||e^{-Bt}||2 = e^{-μ t}(1 − c t^{2 mSHC(B)+1} + O(t^{2 mSHC(B)+2})) as t→0+, citing the semi-dissipative case and using the shift B↦B−μ I (Proposition 2.7 and Corollary 2.12) , with the factorization e^{-Bt}=e^{-μ t}e^{-B̃ t} explicitly noted and the SHC-index defined via the shift (Lemma 2.9/Definition 2.10) . The candidate solution proves the same statement directly: remove the skew part unitarily, analyze H(t)=e^{B̃S t}B̃H e^{-B̃S t} (even in t), derive the order of the first nonzero derivative of g_x(t)=||w(t)||^2, and obtain the exponent 2m+1 with a positive coefficient controlled by λmin(Tm)=λmin(Σ_{j=0}^m S^j H (S^H)^j)>0 (consistent with the paper’s equivalences for the HC-index) . The two arguments are logically compatible; the paper relies on earlier results, while the model gives a self-contained proof sketch with the same exponent and shift.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The manuscript correctly identifies and deploys the shifted hypocoercivity index to capture the short-time decay rate of the semigroup norm, and it cleanly relates continuous- and discrete-time settings. The argument for the general case is a straightforward and correct reduction to the semi-dissipative case combined with an exponential factor. Since the central short-time statement is referenced rather than proved in situ, adding a concise proof sketch or a sharper citation would enhance readability. With minor clarifications and unified attributions, the presentation would be fully polished.