Back to search
2205.00070

Queues with Delayed Information: Analyzing the Impact of the Choice Model Function

Philip Doldo, Jamol Pender

correcthigh confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves that the N-queue DDE with routing probabilities proportional to Ḡ(qi(t−Δ)) has symmetric equilibrium q* = λ/(Nμ) and loses stability at Δcr = arccos(μ/C)/√(C²−μ²), where C = −(λ/N) g(q*)/Ḡ(q*) = −(λ/N) h(q*), valid for C < −|μ|. It linearizes to u̇ = A u(t−Δ) − μu with A = C(I − (1/N)11^T), decomposing into a synchronous mode and N−1 identical asynchronous modes with characteristic equation s + μ − C e^{−sΔ} = 0. These are exactly the steps and formulas used by the candidate solution, which also supplies a standard transversality calculation showing the imaginary pair crosses from stable to unstable as Δ increases past Δcr. Hence, both arguments are correct and essentially the same, with the model adding a minor but standard crossing-direction detail.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The manuscript provides a clean, general stability analysis for delayed-information queues under a broad class of choice models induced by CCDFs, yielding an explicit critical delay in terms of the hazard rate. The derivation is correct and straightforward, and the numerical section is informative. Adding a succinct transversality check (or citing a standard DDE reference) would remove the last implicit step in the Hopf argument, but this is a minor point. Overall, the contribution is solid and useful for specialists in delay-driven queueing dynamics.