Back to search
2205.03904

Theta Neuron Subject to Delayed Feedback: A Prototypical Model for Self-Sustained Pulsing

Carlo R. Laing, Bernd Krauskopf

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper derives, via the V = tan(θ/2) change of variables to the QIF form, an existence condition for (n+1)-spike-per-delay periodic orbits that exactly matches coth[(n+1)T − τ] = κ + coth[nT − τ] in the excitable case and immediately implies κ > 2 (paper eqs. (2), (9)–(10); see also their explicit κ>2 remark) . It then constructs the event-time map, linearizes it, and obtains the same companion-matrix Jacobian with parameter γ and characteristic polynomial g(λ) = λ^{n+1} − γλ^n − 1 + γ, together with the key properties summarized in their Proposition 1 (no Neimark–Sacker or period-doubling for 0<γ, and loss of stability only when a multiplier crosses +1 at γ=(n+1)/n) . The candidate solution reproduces these steps: the existence relation and κ>2 bound; the event-map linearization yielding δt_{k+1} = γ δt_k + (1−γ) δt_{k−n} with the same g(λ); and the full stability picture with the same threshold γ=(n+1)/n, adding standard complex-analytic proofs (Eneström–Kakeya, Rouché) for the location of roots. For the primary branch (n=0) the paper’s explicit T(τ) = τ + coth^{-1}(κ − coth τ) and the reappearance construction lead to closed-form saddle-node loci (eqs. (26)–(27)), identical to those in the candidate solution’s Part C . The paper also identifies superstable points at dT/dτ=0, consistent with the candidate’s observation that γ=1 implies F_τ=0 and thus dT/dτ=0 by implicit differentiation; furthermore, the paper shows γ>0 for both I<0 and I>0 cases and presents the cot/csc analogues for I>0 that the candidate also states . Overall, the methods match point-for-point; the model’s derivations mirror the paper’s argument and results, with minor presentational differences.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper provides an explicit and complete treatment of delayed self-feedback in a canonical phase-reduced neuron model, deriving closed-form existence conditions, stability via a finite-degree polynomial, and precise saddle-node loci across regimes. The results are correct and useful across neuroscience and optics. Minor clarifications would streamline the exposition and aid readers in navigating the various branches and parameter scalings.