Back to search
2208.13573

Metastability for Kawasaki dynamics on the hexagonal lattice

Simone Baldassarri, Vanessa Jacquier

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper defines the model, Hamiltonian H(η)=−U·(# interior bonds)+Δ·(# particles) with bonds counted only in Λ−, and Δ∈(U,3U/2) (reversible Metropolis Kawasaki with open boundary), then proves Xm={empty}, Xs={full} and Φ(empty,full)=ΓK-Hex, with ΓK-Hex given explicitly in two cases depending on δ, plus the e^{βΓK-Hex} time scale and limiting Exp(1) law. These appear in (2.3), Theorem 2.2 and Theorem 2.3, respectively . The “reference path” (upper bound) and the isoperimetric/perimeter-minimization lower bound (via quasi-regular hexagons with bars, EB5(r*) or EB1(r*+1)) yield the barrier (2.32) and gate description (Theorem 2.5) . The candidate solution’s decomposition H=Δ(|S|+|B|)−U·e(S) and 3|S|=2e(S)+p(S) matches the paper’s counting framework and VA-manifold stratification; their exact counting for rings reproduces the coefficients in (2.32), including the “+Δ traveler.” Their canonical (monotone) path and isoperimetric lower bound align with the paper’s Sections 3.2–3.3, and their δ-split gate geometry (five-side truncated ring versus two-segment overshoot) matches EB5(r*) and EB1(r*+1) with added triangles/free particle in Theorem 2.5 . Differences are present only in presentation: the paper characterizes a full gate family K(A*−1)fp, whereas the model summary highlights the two canonical prototypes; for the time law the paper proceeds via pathwise tools while the candidate cites potential-theoretic metastability. Substantively, both are consistent and correct.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The manuscript provides a thorough metastability analysis for Kawasaki dynamics on a hexagonal lattice with open boundaries. It identifies metastable and stable states, delivers an exact communication height with a two-case structure depending on the fractional part δ, and characterizes a gate family. The methodology (reference path and isoperimetric lower bound) is standard yet carefully adapted to the hexagonal geometry and to conservative dynamics. Minor additions to the geometric counting and an explicit remark on the free-particle traveler would improve readability.