Back to search
2208.14327

Some interesting birational morphisms of smooth affine quadric 3-folds

Cinzia Bisi, Jonathan D. Hauenstein, Tuyen Trung Truong

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves positivity and log-concavity for Lefschetz numbers, and log-concavity for the degree sequences on cohomology, using regularization of positive currents via the automorphism group of an odd quadric and an inequality dj(g1∘g2) ≤ dj(g1)dj(g2). The candidate solution gives a clean, purely algebraic correspondence/Künneth-based proof of positivity and L(g^{n+n'}) ≤ L(g^n)L(g^{n'}) that matches the paper’s statements. One caveat: the model’s Step 3 invokes functoriality of the pullback on cohomology for meromorphic maps, which can fail without stability; however, the claimed log-concavity for ||(g^n)^*|| still follows directly from the established inequality for dj(g^n) and the fact H^{2j}(X) is one-dimensional for odd quadrics. With that minor correction, both are correct, using different methods.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The audited proposition is correct and well-motivated. The paper’s argument via regularization of positive currents on a homogeneous quadric is standard and suitably referenced, and the result (log-concavity for Lefschetz numbers and degree sequences) is a useful technical tool for the paper’s broader goals. Minor clarifications would further strengthen the presentation and avoid possible confusion around pullback functoriality for meromorphic maps.