2208.14813
A structure preserving stochastic perturbation of classical water wave theory
Oliver D. Street
correctmedium confidence
- Category
- Not specified
- Journal tier
- Specialist/Solid
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper proves that the free-surface variables (ζ, pφ) form a canonical pair for the stochastic classical water-wave equations by computing the variational derivatives of H and Hi and inserting them into the Stratonovich Hamilton equations (Theorem 1). It derives δH/δ(pφ) = n·x∇φ and δH/δζ = 1/2|p∇rφ|^2 − 1/2(p∂zφ)^2 + p∂zφ[p∇rφ·∇rζ] + gζ, together with δHi/δ(pφ) = n·pξi and δHi/δζ = pξi(r)·p∇rφ + p∂zφ[pξi(r)·∇rζ], using Green’s identities, the divergence theorem, the non-unit normal n = (−∇rζ, 1), and the constrained shape variation δφ = −(∂zφ)δζ on z = ζ (Proposition 3). Substituting these into the Bismut-style canonical SPDEs reproduces the stochastic kinematic boundary condition (3.8) and the stochastic Bernoulli boundary equation (4.5) exactly . The candidate solution follows the same route (same constrained variation, same boundary identities, same divergence-free ξi) and arrives at the identical functional derivatives and canonical SPDEs, hence the two arguments are essentially the same.
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions \textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid \textbf{Justification:} The manuscript rigorously ported Zakharov’s Hamiltonian formalism to a stochastic setting with transport-type noise while preserving canonical variables. The derivations are faithful to the deterministic blueprint and illuminate how stochasticity enters via Hamiltonians Hi. Minor clarifications on analytical assumptions (regularity, boundary conditions, domain) and a brief discussion of symplectic structure in infinite dimensions would enhance the paper’s accessibility and rigor.