Back to search
2212.11704

Measure equivalence embeddings of free groups and free group factors

Tey Berendschot, Stefaan Vaes

correctmedium confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves the group-level ME-embedding (Theorem A) and its weak mixing and stable strong ergodicity via an explicit skew-product and two key propositions: a fundamental-domain criterion relying on ‖λ(ν)‖ < 1/3 (Proposition 3.7) and a “random strong ergodicity” result (Proposition 3.6), combined with the correspondence transfer principle (Proposition 2.4). It also proves the II1-factor characterization (Theorem B) using a concrete cocycle construction and Connes’ averaging to get a norm < 1/3 (Theorem 5.6 + Proposition 5.7). By contrast, the candidate solution assumes, without proof, a crucial compression estimate ∥πY(ν)∥ ≤ 3‖λG(ν)‖ and a general tensor-norm inequality to deduce strong (and stable) ergodicity—claims that are neither established nor used in the paper. It also does not justify the dissipativity/fundamental-domain for the F2-action, which in the paper hinges on the (2k−1)−1 threshold. Hence the conclusions match the paper but the model’s proof contains unproven steps and gaps.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper’s constructions are explicit and the arguments clean. The results bridge ME-embeddings, ergodic properties, and II1-factor analogues, with a neat use of random ergodic theorems and correspondence techniques. Minor additions could improve readability and context.