Back to search
2212.14564

Finding similarity of orbits between two discrete dynamical systems via optimal principle

Yuting Chen, Yong Li

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper obtains the stationarity condition (3.16) for the simple case by writing J(A)=∑||Ax_k−y_k||^2, expanding ∂J/∂a_{ij} termwise as in (3.6) and combining the componentwise derivatives (3.7), (3.11)–(3.15) to reach Proposition 3.1 (equation (3.16)) . For the homotopy case, it analogously sets up J(A,λ) as in (3.22) and applies KKT partial derivatives (3.23)–(3.24) to derive (3.31)–(3.32) . The candidate solution reproduces these conditions in a compact vector-Jacobian notation (DΦ_k), with the same chain-rule content as the paper’s expanded index formulas, and correctly explains the absence of ∂A/∂λ in (3.32) by noting that the derivative is a partial (holding A fixed) and, equivalently, by the envelope theorem at a joint stationary point—exactly how the paper treats (3.24) (no ∂A/∂λ terms) . Minor differences are expository (notation, explicit KKT/boundary comments), not mathematical.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The theoretical core—first-order necessary conditions for the similarity transform—is correct and matches the model’s reconstruction. Revisions should clarify (i) interior vs boundary KKT conditions, (ii) the use of partial derivatives in λ despite writing A = A(λ), and (iii) streamline the heavy index notation with compact Jacobian products. Numerical demonstrations are supportive; the contribution is primarily methodological.