Back to search
2402.01958

Synchronization and averaging in partially hyperbolic systems with fast and slow variables

Federico Bonetto, Guido Gentile

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper establishes (i) a unique invariant manifold W via a Banach fixed-point argument on the sup norm and then quantifies anisotropic Hölder regularity along v±, (ii) sharp L1/L2 deviation bounds and the maximal-probability estimate m0{sup_n (1−ργ′)^{-n}|(S^n)_ϕ − (Φ_{nρ}+W∘A0^n)|>δ} ≤ C10 ρ/δ^3 (Theorem 7), and (iii) convergence in probability of the continuous-time interpolant with exponential weight (Theorem 8). These are proved through a careful translated/auxiliary-map construction and correlation inequalities for A0, not via a Poisson/cohomological equation. In contrast, the candidate solution hinges on solving (I − U)H = f̃ with U(h)=h∘A0 and then telescoping; this is not valid in general (additive Livšic-type obstructions for Anosov maps), and the claimed uniform resolvent bound on functions in the proposed anisotropic Hölder scale is unjustified. It also incorrectly concludes ‖W‖∞ = O(ρ), while the paper shows only probabilistic smallness of W (e.g., ⟨W⟩, ⟨W^2⟩ = O(ρ)) and, in fact, α− = O(ρ) with ‖W‖∞ = O(1) in general. The paper’s arguments are internally consistent and complete; the model’s crucial step (Poisson equation) fails under the stated hypotheses, so the model’s Phase B is incorrect. Key places in the paper: Hypotheses 1–3 and setup (2.9)–(2.10) , construction of W and regularity via (3.2)–(3.3) , anisotropic exponents α± in the scaling regime (Cor. 2.14) , oscillation bounds for W (Theorem 4) and Chebyshev consequence (2.25) , square-mean comparison (Theorem 6) , and the maximal-probability estimate (Theorem 7) with its proof (Lemma 5.1 and (5.1)–(5.3)) , as well as convergence in weighted sup-norm (Theorem 8 and its conclusion) .

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The manuscript develops a robust and carefully executed program to prove synchronization and averaging for a skew-product over an Anosov automorphism, delivering sharp probabilistic bounds and a clear continuous-time conclusion. Its approach avoids cohomological-equation pitfalls by leveraging anisotropic norms and correlation inequalities. Minor clarifications in the most technical parts would further enhance accessibility.