Back to search
2402.10361

Stability of Asymptotic Waves in the Fisher–Stefan Equation

T. T. H. Bui, P. V Heijster, R. Marangell

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves spectral and nonlinear stability for (i) the vanishing state u≡0 on (0,h∞) with ux(t,0)=0, u(t,h∞)=0 via separation of variables, obtaining λn=1−((2n−1)π/(2h∞))2 and the threshold h∞=π/2 for stability, and (ii) the spreading semi-wave ūc on (−∞,0] for 0≤c<2 by computing the essential spectrum using Weyl’s theorem and the far-field dispersion λ=−k2−1+ick, and ruling out point spectrum with Re λ>0 using a Sturm–Prüfer argument; nonlinear stability then follows from Henry’s theory. These steps, equations (5)–(6), (9), (12)–(15), and Theorem 4.2, are explicitly developed in the paper . The candidate solution reproduces (A) the separation-of-variables calculation and threshold exactly, and for (B) gives the same essential spectrum and excludes unstable point spectrum by a ground-state transform using φ(z)=−e^{(c/2)z}ū′c(z)>0, which is an alternative but valid route to the paper’s conclusion. Two small notes: the paper’s brief mention of H^1_0((0,h∞)) for the vanishing problem conflicts with the mixed (Neumann–Dirichlet) boundary conditions, while the candidate’s claim that H^1_0(R_−) is a Banach algebra is not needed (H^1(R_−)→L^4 ensures u↦u^2 maps H^1→L^2). Neither issue affects the main results.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper offers a clear, rigorous treatment of spectral and nonlinear stability for asymptotic states in the Fisher–Stefan problem, combining an essential-spectrum calculation with a careful exclusion of unstable point spectrum and an application of Henry’s semilinear theory. The arguments are compelling and appropriately tailored to the half-line geometry and mixed boundary conditions. A small clarification is warranted regarding the choice of perturbation space in the vanishing case to align with the mixed Neumann–Dirichlet boundary conditions, but this does not affect the main results. The work will be useful to researchers in PDEs and mathematical biology working on moving-boundary models.