Back to search
2403.11591

A Physics-Informed Neural Network Method for the Approximation of Slow Invariant Manifolds for the General Class of Stiff Systems of ODEs

Dimitrios G. Patsatzis, Lucia Russo, Constantinos Siettos

correcthigh confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper frames the SIM as a graph x=h(y) in coordinates (x,y) induced by linear maps X(z)=Cz and Y(z)=Dz, and enforces membership and invariance via L1: Cz−N(Dz)=0 and L2: (C−∇yN(Dz)D)F(z)=0, together with pinning constraints on (C,D), see Eqs. (12–16) and (18,21) for the SLFNN and its derivatives, and the invariance equation in Eq. (11) . It also estimates a constant M over the domain of interest using the CSP diagnostic, Eq. (7) , and explicitly emphasizes that the learned SIM is an explicit functional that avoids root-finding . The candidate solution formalizes the same argument: it picks admissible (C,D) satisfying the paper’s pinning constraints, defines H={z: Cz=h(Dz)}, shows this is a C^1 embedded manifold of dimension N−M and is invariant by differentiating Cz−h(Dz) along trajectories to obtain (C−∇yh(Dz)D)F(z), and derives the reduced y-dynamics; it also notes that an SLFNN h with L1≡0 and L2≡0 yields an explicit reduced model. The only overstatement is the claim that the CSP diagnostic itself guarantees M is constant on an arbitrary Ω; in the paper, constancy is ensured in practice by restricting to time windows/domains where the diagnostic reports a constant M during data collection (Sec. 2.3.1) . Aside from this nuance, the logic is aligned and essentially the same invariance-based proof underlies both.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The manuscript integrates the invariance equation with a PINN architecture to deliver explicit SIM functionals and reduced models, sidestepping root-finding. The methodology is well-motivated and validated on benchmarks. The main clarifications needed concern the practical enforcement (rather than theoretical guarantee) of a constant number of fast modes M via the CSP diagnostic and data selection, and a brief, explicit statement connecting exact satisfaction of the IE to invariance for completeness.