Back to search
2404.07233

Structure of the codimesion one gradient flows with at most six singular points on the Möbius strip

Maria Loseva, Alexandr Prishlyak, Kateryna Semenovych, Yuliia Volianiuk

correcthigh confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper enumerates all Morse (gradient-like) flows on the Möbius strip with up to six singular points via separatrix diagrams and uses a doubling/Poincaré–Hopf index constraint to screen possibilities; it then counts codimension-one bifurcations (SN, SC, BSN, BDS, HN, HS, HSC, BSC). Its stated results — one class for N=3; four for N=4 (with 2 HN, 2 BSN, 1 BDS, 2 HSC, 1 BSC); fifteen for N=5 (with totals 10 SN, 14 SC, 6 BSN, 2 BDS, 4 HN, 10 HS, 4 HSC, 2 BSC); and for N=6 (36 SN, 15 SC, 48 BSN, 21 BDS, 30 HN, 14 HSC, 2 BSC) — match the candidate solution’s counts exactly. The model’s argument is more structural: it justifies completeness via separatrix ribbon diagrams (with cyclic orders and a Möbius parity) and derives the index constraint by doubling to the Klein bottle. The paper does not present the invariant’s completeness formally and contains minor slips (e.g., a misstatement that node indices are 0, and a small inconsistency in the N=4 SN column of Table 1), but its main conclusions and the diagram-based classification agree with the model’s approach and totals.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

Diagrammatic enumeration plus a clean index constraint yields a complete catalog of flows and codimension-one bifurcations on the Möbius strip for small numbers of singular points. The results appear correct, useful, and align with established surface-flow theory. Minor textual issues (a slip in index wording; a small mismatch in Table 1 for N=4) should be corrected. The exposition would benefit from an explicit statement of the completeness invariant and brief justifications for certain boundary-parity claims.