Back to search
2405.08778

Quantum Integrable Systems arising from Separation of Variables on S3

Sean R. Dawson, Holger R. Dullin

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper explicitly derives the prolate separated ODEs (Heun type for s1,s3 and a trivial m-equation after s2=cos^2φ), fixes m∈Z, and obtains energy quantization E=D(D+2) via the Heun polynomial truncation condition (α=−d up to symmetry), see Lemma 12 and Lemma 14–15 with the three-term recurrence for Heun polynomials . It identifies a unique focus–focus critical value at (mℏ,λℏ^2)=(0,1) (magenta dot in Fig. 5) and demonstrates quantum monodromy by transporting a unit cell, yielding (v1',v2')=(v1,v2+2v1) when symmetry classes are combined; per single symmetry class the jump is v2→v2+v1, as observed in prior work . The candidate solution reaches the same conclusions but via an ODE-centered argument: Frobenius exponents show only m=0 is resonant at s=1 (hence the defect lies on μ=0), and, for m=0, an exact λ-involution λ↦2E+2−λ is exhibited with unique fixed point λ=E+1, i.e. Λ=1 after scaling. This nicely explains the location (μ,Λ)=(0,1) and the monodromy v2↦v2+v1 per symmetry class, doubling to v2↦v2+2v1 when two symmetry classes are combined. Minor caveats in the model’s writeup (self-adjointness and limit-circle assumptions sketched but not fully justified; mapping the left/right matching across s=1 to the λ-involution is asserted rather than fully proved) do not affect the main claims. Net: paper and model agree on the results; the model supplies a complementary proof mechanism.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper gives a coherent account of quantum integrable systems from separation on S\^3, including a semi-toric prolate case with a clear quantum monodromy signature. Analytic reduction to Heun form, polynomial truncations, and numerically computed spectra are well presented, and the focus–focus point at (0,1) with its monodromy is convincingly exhibited. Minor clarifications (a brief analytic rationale for the uniqueness and location of the focus–focus value in (μ,Λ)) would strengthen the exposition.