Back to search
2405.13818

Identifiability of Differential-Algebraic Systems

Arthur N. Montanari, François Lamoline, Robert Bereza, Jorge Gonçalves

correcthigh confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper’s Theorem 2 states a rank condition for local identifiability and proves it via a 1-fullness linear-algebra criterion applied to a lifted map Ψ, then invokes the Constant Rank Theorem to pass from linearized uniqueness to local nonlinear uniqueness . The candidate solution establishes the same rank condition and proves identifiability by showing that the level set S = {(θ,z): G(θ,z)=const} is a submanifold with vertical tangents, forcing the θ-projection to be locally constant; equality of outputs on an interval gives equality of finite jets, hence membership in S, which implies θ′=θ0. This differs in style from the paper (geometric level-set argument vs. the paper’s 1-fullness/Ψ argument) but is logically consistent with the paper’s hypotheses and conclusion. Both are correct under the same local smoothness and consistency assumptions (e.g., x0 ∈ L, smooth F and h) .

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The main theorem delivers a practical identifiability test for nonlinear DAEs via an algebraic rank condition, aligning with established geometric reasoning and linear-algebraic 1-fullness. The proof is compact and persuasive, though the Constant Rank Theorem step bridging linearized uniqueness to nonlinear identifiability could be elaborated for maximal clarity. The numerical examples substantiate usefulness. Overall, the contribution is correct, relevant, and clearly presented with minor expository gaps.