Back to search
2406.08462

Periodic Orbits of Non-Degenerate Lacunary Contact Forms on Prequantization Bundles

Miguel Abreu, Leonardo Macarini

correctmedium confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves that every non-degenerate lacunary contact form on a suitable prequantization has precisely r_B simple contractible closed Reeb orbits (Theorem 1.6) using positive S^1-equivariant symplectic homology, the computation HC^0_*(M) ≅ ⊕_{m≥1} H^{*−2mc_B+n}(B;Λ), lacunarity ⇒ vanishing differential, positivity of the mean index, and an index-recurrence/CIJT window-counting argument . The candidate’s solution follows the same architecture: identify HC/CH with SH^{S^1,+}, use the prequantization computation, infer perfection from lacunarity, isolate one good iterate per simple orbit via index recurrence, and count to get r_B. Two technical oversimplifications appear in the candidate solution: (i) the claim that the graded rank in any index window of length <2c_B equals r_B is not established in the paper (which instead uses resonance relations and a carefully chosen truncation about d=2s c_B), and (ii) the uniqueness of one iterate per simple orbit in a wide window is asserted but in the paper is achieved via a narrow window and properties (ii)–(iii) of index recurrence. These are patchable and do not affect the conclusion. Overall, the statement and the proof strategy match; the paper’s version is the rigorous, detailed implementation of the model’s outline.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper establishes an exact multiplicity result under lacunarity on a broad and important class of contact manifolds (prequantizations), sharpening prior lower bounds. The proof is conceptually clean and technically careful, combining positive equivariant symplectic homology, a precise prequantization computation, lacunarity, and index-recurrence/resonance arguments. Exposition is generally clear; a few clarifications (e.g. a short lemma isolating mean-index positivity, and a brief discussion of the chosen index window) would further benefit readers. The result has significance for the r\_B-or-infinity paradigm and may inform related problems on orbifolds and symmetry reductions.