Back to search
2406.14649

A Macroscopic Pedestrian Model with Variable Maximal Density

Laura Bartoli, Simone Cacace, Emiliano Cristiani, Roberto Ferretti

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper’s 1D steady-state analysis in the congested regime (ρ > σ), with u ≡ 0 and θ − β∂xθ = 0, assumes a constant flux f(ρ, τ) = d fmax and uses the triangular fundamental diagram to get (ρ − τ) = d(σ − τ), hence ρ = dσ + (1 − d)τ. Combined with θ = ρ − (τave − ν) and the choice c = 0 (i.e., θ ≡ 0), d = 0, and τ(x) = ax + b, averaging τ over [x, x + δ] yields τave = τ + (aδ)/2, so τ = τave − ν forces a = 2ν/δ. This is exactly the argument and result presented in the paper (Eqns. (4), (6)–(7), (10a–c), (11)–(14) in the 1D steady-state discussion), and the candidate solution follows the same steps to reach the same conclusion .

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} no revision

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

This check concerns a concise steady-state calculation within a newly proposed macroscopic pedestrian model. The paper’s derivation is algebraically clean and correct, and the candidate solution reproduces it step-by-step, reaching the same \$a=2\nu/\delta\$ relation. The only minor omission in the candidate solution is not stating \$u\equiv 0\$ explicitly when invoking stationarity; otherwise, it is fully aligned with the paper.