2407.01357
NON-DENSITY RESULTS IN HIGH DIMENSIONAL STABLE HAMILTONIAN TOPOLOGY
Robert Cardona, Fabio Gironella
correctmedium confidence
- Category
- math.DS
- Journal tier
- Specialist/Solid
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper proves (1) non-density of stable hypersurfaces in dim W ≥ 8 (Theorem 1) and (2) in every regular stable homotopy class on a (2n+1)-manifold with n≥2 there is a SHS that cannot be C2-perturbed to a non-degenerate one (Theorem 2). The core ingredients are: a non-R-covered, volume-preserving Anosov flow whose associated 2-form admits no stabilizer and remains non-stabilizable under C1-small perturbations (Lemma 15) ; a local symplectic embedding and insertion of a 3D NHIM with Anosov dynamics into any hypersurface in dim ≥8 (Propositions 18, 21, 22) ; persistence of NHIMs (Theorem 9) ensuring the obstruction survives C3-approximation, and explaining why C2 is insufficient (Remark 24) ; and, for (2), coupling functions (Lemma 7), a degeneracy criterion (Lemma 28), and a local model that robustly forces a periodic orbit on a regular level set (Proposition 29) . The candidate solution closely mirrors these steps, including the Anosov kernel, NHIM insertion, the C3-threshold reasoning, and the invariant tori with rotation-number continuity. Minor issues: a slight misnumbering of statements and an imprecise phrasing of “coupling functions” (the paper uses functions fi derived from dλ and powers of ω), but these do not affect the logic. Overall, both are correct and follow substantially the same proof.
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} major revisions \textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid \textbf{Justification:} The results are solid and interesting, with a coherent synthesis of dynamics and symplectic topology. The arguments appear correct and novel, especially the robust Anosov-based obstruction and the higher-dimensional non-density statements. Some technical steps would benefit from expanded explanations and more explicit regularity bookkeeping, which would broaden accessibility and reduce the burden on the reader to unpack implicit estimates.