2407.16650
ANOSOV DIFFEOMORPHISMS OF OPEN SURFACES
Snir Ben Ovadia, Jonathan DeWitt
correctmedium confidence
- Category
- Not specified
- Journal tier
- Strong Field
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper proves Theorem 1.5—existence of a Margulis leafwise system {µu} with (1) full support, (2) invariance under stable holonomies, (3) conformal covariance µu_x ∘ f^{-1} = e^{-h} µu_{f(x)}, and (4) infinite mass on rays in periodic unstable leaves—by building a countable Markov partition, constructing harmonic functions on the one–sided shift, and pushing conformal leaf-measures from the symbolic space to M, including a delicate Section 3.5 establishing global holonomy invariance and a proof that h = h_G(σ) > 0 (via finite Gurevich entropy) . The candidate solution instead proposes a direct Carathéodory measure on unstable plaques. It contains a critical error in the extension from local plaques to global leaves: it sends A forward (uses f^k(A) ⊂ W^u_ρ) when contraction along unstable requires pulling A back (use f^{-k}(A) ⊂ W^u_ρ). This breaks the claimed well-definedness and the conformal rule on full leaves. It also does not establish global holonomy invariance across rectangles, a point the paper treats as the main technical hurdle . Further, it unjustifiably asserts that the minimal covering numbers N_x(n) are independent of x. Finally, while the paper proves infinite mass on periodic rays (Lemma 3.33) , the model’s derivation relies on its flawed global extension. Therefore the paper’s argument is correct and complete for its stated hypotheses, whereas the model’s proof is incorrect/incomplete.
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} no revision \textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field \textbf{Justification:} The manuscript gives a careful, complete construction of Margulis measures on unstable leaves for uniform Anosov diffeomorphisms on open surfaces with dense periodic points, using a countable Markov partition, harmonic functions on the associated one-sided shift, and a nontrivial argument for global holonomy invariance. It identifies the conformal factor with the finite Gurevich entropy and proves infinite mass on rays of periodic leaves. The treatment of global holonomy invariance is the main technical contribution, clearly flagged and addressed.