Back to search
2408.03279

Pensive billiards, point vortices, and the silver ratio

Theodore D. Drivas, Daniil Glukhovskiy, Boris Khesin

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper explicitly proves that, in the ε→0 dipole limit, the interior-to-interior map is a pensive billiard with delay ℓ(p) = L − pL/√(1+p^2) for p = cos θ, using the half-plane fission speeds v± = v(√(1+cos^2 θ) ∓ cos θ), near-boundary constant-speed sliding, and the meeting-distance formula 2L·v+/(v++v−) (yielding L(1 − cos θ/√(1+cos^2 θ))) . The specular (angle-preserving) recombination follows by running the half-plane dynamics backward via the fusion rule, ensuring the same θ on exit , consistent with the paper’s narrative that the dipole “reflects from the boundary at the same angle” . The candidate solution reproduces these same steps and formulas (fission speeds, constant sliding, meeting-distance, and angle invariance), so both are correct and essentially the same argument.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The result neatly links point-vortex dynamics with a new class of billiards (pensive billiards) and gives an explicit delay function for the dipole limit. The argument is clear and uses standard tools (half-plane approximation, energy/momentum conservation, mirror method) combined in a clean way. Minor clarifications (assumption set, meeting-time derivation remark) would further aid readers, but the core result and method are sound.