Back to search
2409.05857

Finite Periodic Data Rigidity For Two-Dimensional Area-Preserving Anosov Diffeomorphisms

Thomas Aloysius O’Hare

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves a uniform, quantitative finite–periodic-data rigidity theorem on T^2 via a concrete “weighted holonomy” construction of h_N, leafwise C^{1+α} regularity plus Journé, and an effective equidistribution theorem for periodic points to the SRB measure to get d_{C^0}(h,h_N) ≤ C_0 λ_0^N and d_{C^1}(f,f_N) ≤ C_1 λ_1^N, with constants uniform over a C^2-bounded family U. These ingredients appear explicitly in Theorem 1.1 and the Section 3–6 roadmap (weighted holonomy to ensure continuity across stable leaves, and effective equidistribution for Lipschitz observables) . By contrast, the candidate solution relies crucially on an unproven “finite quantitative Livšic” statement for diffeomorphisms—producing φ = u_N∘f − u_N + r_N with ||r_N|| ≤ Cρ^N from only S_N φ(p)=0 on Fix(f^N)—and then attempts a straightforward holonomy projection without the weighted averaging that the paper explicitly introduces to fix transverse discontinuity issues. The finite Livšic step is nonstandard here and not justified by the cited flow result; and omitting the weighted holonomy leaves a genuine gap the paper itself highlights (the naive leafwise definition need not extend continuously to T^2) .

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} no revision

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper resolves a natural quantitative problem in rigidity with a technically clean and uniform argument. The weighted-holonomy construction directly addresses a known obstruction to global continuity. The new effective equidistribution input is interesting on its own. The exposition is generally clear; only minor organizational tweaks could streamline the reading experience.