Back to search
2409.14962

The Number of Periodic Points of Surface Symplectic Diffeomorphisms

Marcelo S. Atallah, Marta Batoréo, Brayan Ferreira

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper’s Theorem 1.1 states exactly the solver’s claim and proves it via two ingredients: (i) a forcing result (Theorem 1.13) that if a contractible fixed point has nontrivial local Floer homology and nonzero mean index, then for all sufficiently large primes p there is a simple p-periodic orbit, relying on the support of Floer–Novikov homology on surfaces and an isolation-by-blow-up-and-gluing argument; and (ii) a dichotomy (Theorem 1.14) which, under finiteness of contractible fixed points and nontrivial flux, guarantees either such a point exists or there is a symplectically degenerate extremum that also forces simple prime-periodic orbits. The ‘moreover’ part is established by a doubling (blow-up-and-gluing) contradiction comparing the global Floer–Novikov rank to the sum of local ranks. These steps closely match the model’s outline and details, including the use of admissible iterations, mean-index growth, support windows, and the gluing construction. See Theorem 1.1 and its discussion; the proof outline for Theorem 1.13; the dichotomy Theorem 1.14; the local Floer support window; and the blow-up-and-gluing discussion used in both the forcing and ‘moreover’ arguments.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The work furnishes a robust, Floer–Novikov–theoretic criterion ensuring infinitely many periodic points on surfaces of positive genus, with a sharp threshold expressed in terms of local Floer homology ranks. The main forcing mechanism via mean-index growth plus blow-up-and-gluing, together with a clean dichotomy through symplectically degenerate extrema, is executed carefully. Minor clarifications would further strengthen readability, but the core arguments are correct and valuable.