2411.09530
Discrete Dirac structures and discrete Lagrange–Dirac dynamical systems in mechanics
Linyu Peng, Hiroaki Yoshimura
correcthigh confidence
- Category
- Not specified
- Journal tier
- Specialist/Solid
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper’s Theorem 5.16 is proved by a direct specialization of the general discrete Dirac-structure construction (Theorem 5.7) from an arbitrary manifold M to M=T*Q, together with the specific (+/−) discrete flat maps and lifted constraints; see the statement and proof of Theorem 5.16 and the general result in Theorem 5.7 . The candidate solution follows the same route: it (i) recalls the general theorem, (ii) identifies the twisted finite-difference maps and the resulting discrete canonical flat maps (Ωd±)♭ on T*Q in local form, (iii) computes the annihilators (Δd±_{T*Q})^∘ using the discrete pairing, and (iv) applies the general theorem to conclude maximal isotropy and hence a discrete Dirac structure. These steps match the paper’s definitions and local formulas for (Ωd±_{T*Q})♭ (i.e., ((q0,p0),(q1,p1)) ↦ (q1,p1,−p̂+_1,q̂−_1) and (q0,p0,−p̂−_0,q̂+_0)) and for the annihilators ((Δd+_{T*Q})^∘(q1,p1) = {(η,ξ): η∈Δ^∘_Q(q1), ξ=0}, and similarly for −), as well as the discrete dual pairing used to derive them . Consequently, both the paper and the model establish the same result by substantially the same proof.
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions \textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid \textbf{Justification:} The result is correct and well-structured: the discrete induced Dirac structures on T*Q follow cleanly by specializing the general discrete Dirac-structure theorem. The local formulas for the discrete flat maps, pairings, and annihilators are consistent with the twisted discretizations and support the theorem. Minor expository enhancements (explicitly noting the role of free momentum differences and stating regularity assumptions) would improve readability without changing substance.