Back to search
2412.01437

MAXIMAL EQUICONTINUOUS FACTOR AND MINIMAL MAP ON FINITELY SUSLINEAN CONTINUA

Aymen Daghar

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves that any minimal map on a finitely Suslinian continuum is conjugate to an irrational circle rotation, via: (i) monotonicity of the maximal equicontinuous factor (MEF) for onto maps on locally connected continua, (ii) non–weak mixing on finitely Suslinian continua, (iii) identification of the equicontinuous factor as a circle rotation, and (iv) a lemma forcing the factor map to be a homeomorphism once all fibres have empty interior. These steps are present and coherent in the PDF. The candidate solution mirrors the paper but contains a critical gap in Step 5: it claims that the existence of a nontrivial asymptotic pair would force periodicity on the equicontinuous factor. In general, an asymptotic pair in the extension only implies the pair lies in the same fibre; it does not force periodicity of a minimal isometry. The correct argument uses minimality to obtain a return of a point to the interior of a fibre, yielding a periodic point on the factor and hence a contradiction with irrational rotation. Thus the paper’s proof is correct; the model’s proof is not complete as written.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper gives a clean classification of minimal maps on finitely Suslinian continua, completing and generalizing known results from graphs and local dendrites. The method—monotone MEF on locally connected continua, no weak mixing for FS continua, identification of the factor as a circle rotation, and a structural lemma yielding conjugacy—is correct and well-motivated. Minor notational slips and an implicit reliance on minimal recurrence in the final step should be made explicit to improve clarity.