Back to search
2501.03542

Turbulence modeling over riblets via domain transformation

Mohammadamin Naseri, Armin Zare

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper and the candidate solution use the same perturbative decomposition in the riblet height α, the same block-harmonic/operator structure for Aθ and Xθ, and the same decomposition of the steady Lyapunov equation into smaller Sylvester/Lyapunov problems. The paper states and implements the Toeplitz/diagonal structure and α-ordered Lyapunov hierarchy and mean-flow corrections, while the model solution gives a more formal operator-level sketch (with standard assumptions) and makes explicit the symmetry-driven O(α) vs O(α^2) selection rule and a conditional monotonicity statement. Where the paper provides empirical/analytic evidence (e.g., KH-window growth with riblet size), the model adds clear hypotheses to draw a monotonicity conclusion. No substantive contradictions were found; both are consistent and largely the same proof strategy for the core structural results.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

A well-constructed perturbative framework connects riblet geometry to linearized turbulence dynamics and statistics. The paper's order-by-order formulation, structural reduction of Lyapunov equations, and detailed spectral analyses are correct and persuasive, with results consistent with DNS and prior literature. Minor clarifications on operator assumptions and explicit statements about when first-order terms may vanish would enhance clarity. The candidate solution’s formal arguments align with the paper’s approach and provide helpful conditions for certain conclusions (e.g., monotonicity) without contradicting the paper.