Back to search
2501.12843

Integrable Birkhoff Billiards inside Cones

Andrey E. Mironov, Siyao Yin

correcthigh confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves: (i) a quadratic first integral I=|Q|^2 for conical billiards and spherical caustics (Theorem 1), (ii) finiteness of reflections in C^3 convex cones (Theorem 2), and (iii) integrability in a strong sense via 2n−1 (a.e. smooth) first integrals that separate trajectories, obtained by lifting functions from ψ+ after extending the billiard map by the identity there (Theorem 3) . The construction of integrals uses the final direction components v_i and a tangential “moment” built from projecting Q against a continuous extension X(v) of the normal field from Γ to D, plus the quadratic integral; smoothness holds off a codimension-1 set ∆ and the quadratic integral disambiguates on ∆ (Examples/Lemmas 12–15) . The candidate solution mirrors these exact steps: identifying Ψ⊂TS^{n−1}, extending μ by Id on ψ+, lifting functions via τ(x), using final direction plus a projected “tangential moment,” noting smoothness loss only on a glancing set, and using |Q|^2 to separate trajectories on ∆. Minor omissions in the candidate (e.g., the compatibility condition f(v,Q)=f(σ(v,Q)) on ∆0 for continuity of the lifted integral, and the precise boundary decomposition of Ψ) do not alter the core argument, which is materially the same as the paper’s construction .

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper introduces a genuinely new integrable billiard class (cones) and proves integrability in a strong, trajectory-separating sense. The methodology—quadratic integral, finiteness of reflections, and lifting of terminal data from ψ+—is clear and well-motivated. Technical components (phase-space diffeomorphisms, boundary analysis, continuity across Δ0) appear correct. Minor clarifications would improve readability but do not affect the substance.