Back to search
2502.08349

Stability of N-front and N-back solutions in the Barkley model

Christian Kuehn, Pascal Sedlmeier

correcthigh confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper states and proves (by invoking Sandstede’s general theorem after verifying its hypotheses) that, for the Evans–pencil eigenvalue problem Y' = (DXF(γ_{f,N}(ρ)(ξ), ω_N(ρ), r) + λ B(ξ))Y built along the N-front, there is a δ>0 independent of N such that exactly 2N+1 eigenvalues lie in U_δ(0), with asymptotics λ_{2k−1} = (a_{2k−1}+o(1))ρ and λ_{2k} = (a_{2k}+o(1))ρ^{β_ε^2+η_k}, and λ_{2N+1}=0; moreover sign(a_i) = sign(M_f) or sign(M_b), and since M_f,M_b<0, all small eigenvalues lie in the left half-plane. These statements are explicit in Theorem 3.15 together with the setup (176)–(179) and negativity result (190) for the Melnikov integrals, and the recursion defining η_k (171)–(172) . The candidate solution reconstructs the same structure using the standard Evans–Lin reduction: it factors the Evans function via a lower block-triangular Lin matrix, applies Rouché and the implicit function theorem, and concludes the same counting and asymptotics, as well as δ independent of N. This is essentially the method underlying the cited Sandstede theory. One minor difference is that the model explicitly asserts the small eigenvalues are real and negative; the paper only asserts they lie in the left half-plane (consistent with the sign information), but given the real leading-order coefficients this is a benign strengthening rather than a contradiction.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The core stability result follows rigorously from a standard framework once the hypotheses are checked, and the manuscript succeeds in verifying these conditions for the Barkley model. The eigenvalue asymptotics and sign information are clear and consistent with the theory. Minor improvements in exposition would help readers unfamiliar with the Evans–Lin machinery appreciate how the abstract theorem yields the concrete spectral description near the origin and the independence of δ from N.