2504.02189
Solvable Structures for Hamiltonian Systems
Saša Krešić–Jurić, Concepción Muriel, Adrian Ruiz
correcthigh confidence
- Category
- Not specified
- Journal tier
- Strong Field
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper proves a canonical solvable structure for completely integrable Hamiltonian systems by passing to action–angle variables and constructing G_i via a linear-ansatz Gi = Σ_j g_{ij}(P) Q_j; the required commutators are enforced by solving linear PDEs and linear systems using the invertibility of DF, culminating in Theorem 3.1 (see (14)–(16), (17)–(21), (27)–(31), and Theorem 3.1). The candidate solution instead applies the Carathéodory–Jacobi–Lie theorem to choose local canonical coordinates (F,G) with {F_i,G_j}=δ_ij and {G_i,G_j}=0, which yields a valid special case of the paper’s structure with f^l_{ij}=0 and h_{il}=−∂^2H/∂F_i∂F_l. These two approaches are compatible: the paper allows nonzero f^l_{ij} in general, while the model realizes a particular choice where they vanish. Theorem 3.1 and its construction in the paper support the model’s argument as a legitimate local instance of the canonical solvable structure .
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions \textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field \textbf{Justification:} The manuscript gives a clear and effective construction of canonical solvable structures for completely integrable Hamiltonian systems and shows how the associated Pfaffian forms recover action–angle variables and integrate the dynamics. The approach is natural and complements the Arnold–Liouville theorem with a computational framework. The results appear correct, with illustrative examples (harmonic oscillators, Calogero–Moser). Minor clarifications about locality/globality and consistent wording (top vs. lower Pfaffian forms) would further improve readability.