Back to search
2504.11751

Wandering Flows on the Plane

Joseph Auslander, Roberto De Leo

correctmedium confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

Both texts establish the same classification: two regular flows on R^2 are topologically equivalent iff there is a homeomorphism between their orbit (leaf) spaces that preserves the precedence relation ≻ on inseparable separatrices. In the paper, this appears as Theorem 3 and is proved via Kaplan’s chordal systems: preservation of ≻ determines the chordal relations (Lemmas 4.24 and 4.27) and then Theorem J′ lifts a chordal (anti-)isomorphism to a plane homeomorphism carrying oriented leaves to oriented leaves . The necessity direction (flow equivalence induces a homeomorphism of orbit spaces that preserves ≻) is also shown in the paper’s proof of Theorem 3 . The candidate solution proves the same theorem but via Haefliger–Reeb’s classification of oriented foliations by their non-Hausdorff 1-manifold leaf spaces plus the intrinsic left/right order; it identifies ≻ with the right/left order and then applies the lifting theorem. The only notable gap in the model is that the identification “≻ equals ‘right’ non-separation” is stated with a brief sketch rather than a fully rigorous derivation; the paper circumvents this by a detailed chordal-relations development. Otherwise, the arguments align in substance.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The main classification result is correct and clearly situated within the classical theory of planar foliations. The paper provides a coherent chordal-systems route to the theorem, carefully tying the prolongational precedence relation on separatrices to chordal data and leveraging Kaplan’s classification. The exposition could be streamlined slightly where the determination of chordal relations from ≻ is established and where the relation to the Haefliger–Reeb framework is mentioned, but not used. Overall, the results make a solid, specialized contribution that clarifies how the Auslander stream/prolongational structure encodes topological equivalence for regular planar flows.