Back to search
2505.05980

Siegel–Radon transforms of transverse dynamical systems

Michael Björklund, Tobias Hartnick

correcthigh confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper’s Theorem 3.12 proves the adjointness ⟨S_{ψ_ξ} f, ϕ⟩_X = ⟨f, S^*_{ψ_ξ} ϕ⟩_{H\G} by applying Corollary 2.5 to the H-invariant kernel F_{f,ϕ}(g,y)=f(g)ϕ(g^{-1}.y)ψ_ξ(y), which turns the H\G×Y integral into the X-fiber sum directly; this uses the global unimodularity assumptions on G and H and the standard quotient integration formula fixed in §1.1 and Remark 2.4 (eq. (2.5)) . The candidate solution obtains the same identity via Proposition A’s transverse measure identity (1.2), inserting a compactly supported cutoff κ and a normalizing factor J(Hg)=∫_H κ((hg)^{-1})dm_H(h) to match the disintegration over H\G; the ξ-covariances cancel after unfolding by (2.5), yielding exactly the desired pairing. Under the paper’s standing unimodularity and integrability assumptions, the model’s steps (Tonelli/Fubini, boundedness of ψ_ξ, finiteness of σ, quotient integration) are justified by Proposition A and Remark 2.4 (and by the very definitions of S_{ψ_ξ} and S^*_{ψ_ξ}) . Minor details the model leaves implicit (positivity/continuity of J on the compact support and explicit invocation of unimodularity) are standard and align with the paper’s hypotheses, so both arguments are correct and independent.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The manuscript introduces and proves a general twisted Siegel–Radon duality for integrable transverse systems with clear normalization choices and a compact proof based on an H-invariant kernel and a transverse measure identity. The results are of clear interest to harmonic analysis and dynamics (e.g., aperiodic order), and the exposition is concise. Minor clarifications about when unimodularity and specific measure decompositions are invoked would further smooth the reading experience.