Back to search
2505.10428

A Study of Directional Entropy Arising from Z × Z+ Semigroup Actions

Hasan Akın

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper states and proves an upper bound for the directional measure-theoretic entropy of the Z^2-action generated by a 1D linear cellular automaton and the shift under a Bernoulli measure: 0 ≤ h_E(Φ) ≤ |H|(A−ℓ)·H(c), in the regime of “B not large” (i.e., for slopes with −A ≤ B/H ≤ −ℓ). This is Theorem 3 in the paper’s Section 3.1 on Bernoulli measures, which relies on the standard directional-window definition, the scaling property h_{U E}(Φ)=|U|h_E(Φ), and generator partitions . The candidate solution derives the same inequality by an explicit light-cone counting argument for the window W((ρ,1),L,C), using η (the one-site partition) as a generator, the independence under μ_c, and the monotone nesting of base-coordinate intervals when −A ≤ ρ ≤ −ℓ. It also correctly excludes the horizontal case H=0, where the inequality with factor |H| would be trivial but not informative; the paper’s proof framework similarly treats H≠0 through its window definition, and horizontal directions are handled separately via lattice directions Φ(B,0) (equal to f^B) . Thus, the model reproduces the same bound with a different but standard proof; both are correct, with a minor clarification needed in the paper to state H≠0 explicitly in Theorem 3.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The audited theorem and its proof strategy conform to established methods in directional entropy for cellular automata. The model solution correctly reproduces the bound via a standard light-cone counting and independence argument. Two small clarifications would improve the paper’s precision: (i) explicitly restrict the Bernoulli bound to H≠0 (since the horizontal case is treated separately), and (ii) replace the phrase “B not large” by the precise slope interval −A ≤ B/H ≤ −ℓ. With these tweaks, the exposition will be clear and robust for the intended audience.