2505.15562
On Triangular Forms for x-Flat Control-Affine Systems With Two Inputs
Georg Hartl, Conrad Gstöttner, Markus Schöberl
correctmedium confidence
- Category
- Not specified
- Journal tier
- Strong Field
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper proves that for any x-flat two-input control-affine system with differential difference d, after at most d-fold prolonging each input, the system is static-feedback equivalent to the general triangular form (GTF) with the given flat output appearing as (z1, zk1+1). This is stated in Theorem 2 and proved in Appendix B by showing the codistributions Q_{R-1},...,Q_{R+d-1} are integrable via explicit span equalities (e.g., span{dφ[0,R−1]}=span{dx, dū1[0,d−1]}) . The candidate’s solution reaches the same conclusion using the same core idea: construct a flat chart where the codistributions become coordinate codistributions and hence integrable, invoking the GTF characterization based on integrability of codistributions . Differences: (i) the candidate adds an extra claim that any p with 2p≥d suffices; the paper only guarantees p=d (though it exhibits examples where fewer prolongations suffice), and it does not prove the general 2p≥d bound, so that strengthening is unsupported here . (ii) The candidate invokes a decoupling-matrix normalization step that is not needed in the paper’s proof. Overall, the main statement and the integrability mechanism are aligned, and the proofs are substantially the same at the level of core logic (integrability of the codistribution chain after d prolongations using the flat-output parameterization) .
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions \textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field \textbf{Justification:} The paper’s main theorem provides a clean, general bound (≤d prolongations) ensuring SFE to a unifying triangular form for all x-flat control-affine two-input systems. The argument is concise and correct, hinging on a codistribution characterization and a transparent prolongation-based integrability proof. The contribution clarifies the landscape of triangular normal forms and enables practical testing strategies. Presentation is clear; a few added clarifications would further aid readers.