Back to search
2506.07189

On gauge transforms of autonomous ordinary differential equations

Giuseppe Gaeta, Sebastian Walcher

correctmedium confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper’s identification criterion (Proposition 4) states that an analytic nonautonomous field q(t,x)=c(t)+C(t)x+∑_{j≥2}q_j(t,x) is a gauge transform of some autonomous analytic f iff there exist a constant matrix B and an invertible A(t) with A(0)=I such that Ȧ=CA−AB, c(t)=A(t)c(0), and q_j(t,x)=A(t)q_j(0,A(t)^{-1}x) for all j≥2; this follows by comparing homogeneous terms in the equality q(t,x)=ȦA^{-1}x+Af(A^{-1}x), and conversely by defining f(x)=c(0)+Bx+∑_{j≥2}q_j(0,x) (Propositions 3–4) . The candidate solution reproduces exactly this necessity-and-sufficiency argument, including the normalization A(0)=I (as in Remark 5) and termwise comparison of constant, linear, and higher-order homogeneous parts, thereby matching the paper’s proof structure step-for-step . Analyticity and local Taylor expansions are assumed as in the paper’s Section 4 setup, which the candidate also invokes explicitly . Hence both are correct and essentially identical in method.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper gives a clean, correct characterization of gauge transforms of autonomous ODEs and connects them to structural properties (symmetries, normalization) with an explicit identification criterion. The exposition is clear and the examples are instructive. Minor editorial improvements could make domain/locality assumptions and normalization steps even more transparent for practitioners.