2507.14678
Exterior differential systems on Lie algebroids and the invariant inverse problem of the calculus of variations
Tom Mestdag, Kenzo Yasaka
correctmedium confidence
- Category
- math.DS
- Journal tier
- Specialist/Solid
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper’s Theorem 1 states exactly the equivalence between the existence of a reduced multiplier matrix k_ij and a Lie–algebroid 2-form Ω of maximal rank with Ω(Wi,Wj)=0, ι_{Γ0}Ω=0, and δΩ=0, on the IP Lie algebroid with adapted frame {Γ0,Wi,Hi} . The paper proves that any such Ω must be of the form Ω = k_ij Ψ^i∧Θ^j (no H∧H term) via L_{Γ0}Ω=0 (using ι_{Γ0}Ω=0 and δΩ=0) , and computes δΩ on the triples (Γ0,Wi,Wj), (Γ0,Wi,Hj), (Γ0,Hi,Hj), (Wi,Wj,Hk) to recover precisely the reduced Helmholtz conditions (symmetry, dynamical equation in λ, φ-compatibility, and integrability) , with the remaining δΩ(Wi,Hj,Hk) and δΩ(Hi,Hj,Hk) implications shown to be redundant consequences (eqs. (27)–(28)) . The candidate solution reproduces the same adapted-frame brackets (Lemma 1) and dual-coframe exterior derivatives used in the paper , defines Ω = k_ij W^i∧H^j, and checks δΩ on the same families of triples to derive the same conditions. One minor imprecision is the claim that, from Ω(W,W)=0 and ι_{Γ0}Ω=0 alone, “the only possibly nonzero pairings … involve one W and one H”; the paper rightly uses L_{Γ0}Ω=0 (hence δΩ=0 as well) to eliminate a possible H∧H component before concluding Ω has only W–H blocks . Aside from this small clarity issue, the reasoning and structure match the paper’s proof.
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions \textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid \textbf{Justification:} The equivalence between reduced multipliers and closed maximal-rank 2-forms on the IP Lie algebroid is correctly established with clear computations. The derivations of the coframe structure equations and the identification of Helmholtz conditions via δΩ are sound. Minor clarifications (removal of potential H∧H components via L\_{Γ0}Ω=0 and a brief account of redundant conditions) would enhance readability without altering results.