Back to search
2509.11700

Quantization Errors, Human–AI Interaction, and Approximate Fixed Points in L1(µ)

Faruk Alpay, Hamdi Alakkad

incompletemedium confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:57 AM

Audit review

The paper states and aims to prove that any nonempty bounded closed convex K ⊂ L1(μ) that is compact in the topology of local convergence in measure has normal structure and hence the fixed point property for nonexpansive maps (Theorem 1), and it sketches an argument via uniform integrability and a midpoint contradiction . However, the proof as written relies on unattested diameter attainment at several steps and a “by symmetry/relabeling” move that does not follow from the hypotheses, leaving essential gaps. By contrast, the model’s solution correctly invokes Lennard’s 1991 result (uniform Kadec–Klee in measure) to conclude normal structure on τ-compact convex sets, and then applies Kirk’s theorem to obtain a fixed point; this path is standard and complete. The paper’s main claim matches known results (the introduction cites Lennard), but the provided in-text proof needs repair; definitions and context for measure–compactness and uniform integrability are otherwise consistent with the literature in the uploaded PDF .

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} major revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The central fixed point claim on measure–compact convex sets in L1 matches established results and underpins the paper’s subsequent quantization and HITL applications. However, the provided proof of normal structure contains gaps: it uses diameter attainment without justification and a relabeling/symmetry step that does not follow from the hypotheses. These issues are likely fixable via ε–approximate selections and a careful limiting argument grounded in uniform integrability and local convergence in measure. Once repaired, the manuscript would present a cohesive, self-contained argument that supports the novel applied sections.